Still a 4.5 from me......but wanted to get the overall score up higher because it deserves more than a 3, IMO. Really need to get the half points included in these reviews. I gave it a 4 originally, and the other reviewer a 3......but it still came out to a 3 between the two of us. Since I was leaning on the higher side of 4, I'm giving it a 5 now to give a better representation.
The other part of the amendment is this......I stated it was "insulated". This is not correct. They are only lined with the waterproof membrane, and so they seem lightly insulated. They are warm in colder temps, but not to the point of overheating......and I have worn them in summer and they breathe well.
Finally, these reviews should include more than just about the shoe itself. Rogan's is great! Incredible prices and fantastic service/shipping speed every time. Definitely give THEM a 5 out of 5!
By Mark Curtis from Greeley, CO